The Black Prince by Iris Murdoch

A Severed Head; The Black Prince; The Sea, the SeaA Severed Head; The Black Prince; The Sea, the Sea by Iris Murdoch
My rating: 1 of 5 stars

This was the last story in a book of three, so this is going to focus on The Black Prince and Murdoch’s general style. Each of Murdoch’s stories is centered around one character with some egregious emotional flaw: selfishness, extravagant insecurity, obsessiveness, misogyny, an inability to see other people as human beings. Her main characters find their downfall, and sometimes redemption, through their faults. Letters feature periodically in the stories. The Sea, The Sea and The Black Prince are both “written” by the main characters, as memoirs at the end of their lives. Marriages factor heavily in all three stories and there are frequent remarks by one or other characters about what “private” places marriages are. Private here is a synonym for inscrutable. Deep. Mysterious. Often this opinion is espoused by a character who has never been married. Or divorced long ago. A string of acrimoniously ended relationships. Is it marriage that is so depthless? Or is it just that we can never fully comprehend any intimate connection between two people, especially one which has existed for decades? Two people can perceive the same event very differently. Two people can perceive the same person very differently, a concept Murdoch explores more fully in The Black Prince.

The Black Prince is a complicated tale with an unreliable narrator who may or may not be making his story up out of whole cloth. Additional pieces get sewn on in the form of postscripts by other unreliable characters. Everyone is full of lies, and when Bradley Pearson isn’t lying he’s blathering on about Art and struggle and how the True Artist refuses to profane the god of Art with anything less than a perfect offering even if it means never producing anything at all. Pearson believes his “inability to create is continuously significant.” (29) As if one learns and improves through will power alone, instead of practice. His rambling, didactic, sluggish monologues are agony. Murdoch’s luscious descriptions don’t seem to crop up as often here as in her other offerings. Possibly because she allowed Pearson to do the writing, and his voice is completely different from her own. I kept having to resist the urge to flip back to one of the other novels and read it instead. I kept flipping to the end of this one to see how many more pages were left. Not a good sign. While all the books had elements of sexism in them, with toxic masculinity and objectification of women, misogyny seemed to figure more strongly in The Black Prince. Murdoch herself takes the time to describe both genders, which I’ve found is a refreshing novelty in an author. She does tend to emphasize the women’s attractiveness. Its daily fluctuations are minutely catalogued. In a way it’s a relief to have women who aren’t constantly, stunningly, gorgeous. Pearson himself struggles to view women as autonomous beings. He writes about his love interest’s entire life being some sort of construction pre-ordained to push him through strife into greatness, to allow him to suffer so he can create his masterpiece of literature (this book). He makes grand pronouncements about never contacting her, never seeing her, never telling her, and immediately breaks them. It’s equally tragic and comic. There is nothing he succeeds at. It’s hard to believe he has any redeeming qualities. Many of the characters are reprehensible, at least from Pearson’s perspective. Don’t read this book if you’re feeling down about humanity. It won’t help you feel better. Find a charity to volunteer for.

Content warnings for: violence, suicide, murder, rape, maybe abduction, maybe abuse, and some weird attitudes surrounding characters with Jewish ancestors. And a whole Lolita-esque plotline that made me wonder if Nabokov or Murdoch read the other growing up. They had some very common elements. If you hated Lolita with the passion of a thousand fiery suns, it might not hurt to give The Black Prince a pass and read all of Murdoch’s other brilliant, intricate works first. I don’t want to say you won’t be missing out, but you won’t feel like you’re missing out unless you’ve flipped the final page of the last book and find you’re still craving more Murdoch. If you get to that point, then you can read The Black Prince.

View all my reviews

Advertisements

17 thoughts on “The Black Prince by Iris Murdoch

  1. Cheryl Ernst

    You end much more charitably than I expected!

    Also, just a thought of whether you could use a separate entry or something for your “trigger” info at the end of your review? I find it slightly jarring to be cruising along, enjoying your review and then suddenly run into a mundane list of items to watch for. Though, looking back at it, I realize that you do preface the last paragraph with “Content warning”. It just didn’t seem like enough, especially because you then morph into reviewer mode with some really good writing. I don’t know. Maybe just me.

    Overall, great job!

    Like

    1. That’s a good point. I’ll do some thinking and see if I can introduce it a little differently. I don’t want to make it a whole separate entry, but maybe I can work it in more smoothly.

      Like

  2. Christine: I love your reviews, as I’ve told you now several times. I actually laughed out loud when you wrote the bit about volunteering. I notice that you are on WordPress. I am seriously considering restarting my blog on a new site, but I worry about the price. Do you endorse WordPress? Is the price you pay per month worth it?

    Like

    1. I’m actually just using their free site right now, if you don’t register your own domain name it doesn’t cost anything. So I really can’t speak to the value of their paying site. Sorry! I do read another blog on WordPress that’s registered and seems to be going quite well; it’s Captain Awkward. Maybe if you look at their site you’ll get a better idea?

      Like

  3. this site may harm your computer

    Hey there just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

    The words in your post seem to be running off the screen in Firefox.
    I’m not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet browser
    compatibility but I thought I’d post to let you know.
    The style and design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Thanks

    Like

    1. So it sounds like it’s a browser compatibility issue, although support says it may help to clear your cache/cookies and reload the site from scratch. I also tweaked the layout a bit, which hopefully will change how things load. I hope that helps. Thanks for your feedback!

      Like

  4. ασφαλεια αυτοκινητου smart

    Verry quickly thᥙs site will be famous among аll blogging and site-building visitors, dᥙe
    to it’ѕ nice posts

    Like

  5. Aleida

    Way cool! Some vsry valid рoints! I apрreciate ʏߋu writing this
    write-up and аlso the rest оf the site is also reallly gߋod.

    Like

  6. http://maxinehager44132.Onesmablog.com/

    Superb post, thanks and we want more! Added you to FeedBurner.

    Like

  7. computer service miami

    Adoring the info on this site, you have done an excellent job on the blog posts.

    Like

  8. computer repair miami Gardens

    Excellent information, better yet to find out your blog that
    has a great layout. Effectively done

    Like

  9. Maybell

    I went over this website and I think you have plenty
    of excellent info, saved to bookmarks.

    Like

Comments are closed.